antedeluvian 4/26/2012 2:40:59 PM User Rank Blogger
Re: Morse and Vail
Rich
I would imagine there were many including some of the greats.
Edison for example had a whole lab working for him with no credits given. Apprently the light bulb was registered just ahead of someone else's claim.
I have read stories that Alexander Graham Bell may even have copied his design from elsewhere, but to let his calim stay intact he was just ahead of Elisha Gray.
There is even a claim from New Zealand that someone flew before the Wright Brothers.
Rich Quinnell 4/26/2012 2:25:09 PM User Rank Blogger
Morse and Vail
Paulyvee, I had never heard that story before, but it intrigued me and I wanted to know more. I found the full story about Morse and his partner Alfred Vail at the Quarter Century Wireless Association website. Since Morse got the patent in his name alone, we credit him with the invention. I wonder how often creators like Vail get shut out in this way?
BTW, I noticed that the story ascribes the code -.-. (dah-dit-dah-dit) to the letter J while my recollection is that -.-. is C and J is .--- (dit-dah-dah-dah). Unless the author is describing an early version of the code, or unless Morse changed Vail's assignments, the author has made a careless mistake, which leads me to wonder if other parts of the article are wrong, also.
paulyvee 4/26/2012 2:01:32 PM User Rank Bit twiddler
Re: In with the old, to help out the new
I had to develop an indicator unit from a number of lecture rooms to a kitchen facility so that attendees in the rooms could request coffee/tea. We are talking 30 odd years ago and the only technology at that time was a single channel hand held remote transmitter/receiver and programmable gate arrays. I used a similar two bit code to identify each room remote to a receiver in the corridor and then decoded it via the PGA to the indicator - verrrry crude by today's standards but that was all we had.
By the way - it would appear that Mr. Morse did not actually invent the code. he was not so much an inventor as an entraprenour. The code was invented by his lab tech - but developed by Morse following experiments that "showed" that communication was not possible over long distances because of cable losses.
His lab tech (I can't remember the guy's name) disproved the range limitations and invented/developed a very sensitive receiver and while doing this invented the code as a test medium.
Morse then apparently took his experiments and developed the code from this.
However don't ask me where I got this info - I only remember it from discussions with my Morse trainer many many many - and more - years ago.
Well Nemos, using Morse as a machine- and man-readable MCU interface is certainly not a new idea. I'm pretty sure I remember seeing its application maybe 30 years ago in a BYTE magazine article. It does offer a lot of advantages though. The "dot-dash" code for any character -- numbers and punctuation included -- fit nicely into one byte in a look-up table, for example. But you really only need the twenty six alphabetic characters to handle every command&control interface I've ever built, and most commands can be expressed in four characters at most (since the context that you're communicating in is very narrow).
The key to making the command part of the interface work reliably is to adopt a simple "command & confirm" protocol. You send a command using the key, the MCU plays the command back to you, and if it's correct you confirm it by sending a "foolproof" confirmation character ("T" or "E" work well!).
Writing all this in assembly is a great way to teach kids the joys of programming.
Years ago, I was working with a team that was developing a family of high-speed CMOS logic. CMOS logic at the time was (and probably still is) notorious for generating BIG Vdd power transients each time it makes a 0 ->1 or 1 -> 0 transition.
To try to convince the design guys that this was a problem, I took a hex inverter and connected it up as a simple, pretty high frequency ring oscillator. Instead of the usual decoupling capacitor from Vdd to ground, I cut a quarter-wave whip antenna (about 10cm long) out of some hook-up wire and soldered it to the Vdd pin of the inverter package. I cut another whip the same lenght and connected it to a scope probe located at the other end of our building. This was a dandy transmitter that did a nice job of sending Morse over about 100 meters with no difficulty :-) (The FCC did not seem to notice, but might have if we'd made a few hundred thousand of these transmitters -- which we sort of did, now that I think about it -- but never mind.)
I'm convinced that Morse's invention is still relevant, even in today's technology, as a man- and machine-compatible communications protocol that a) can be implemented for less that fifteen cents on any MCU, b) using just one I/O bit, and c) can give you a fully-capable human command and control interface with a very small memory footprint.
(I did know a guy once that could listen to his telephone modem and "read" what was being sent -- but that's another story...)
MicroPower 4/15/2012 8:02:22 PM User Rank Program Manager
Morse project
This reminds me of an earlier project I did quite sometimes ago in college. Out of curiosity, I tried to create a Morse code generator that transmitted Morse codes using a simple push button. In order to prove it worked, I used one of the local radio station frequency then listened to that same radio station. And it worked, even though I don't know how far it transmitted and gave annoyances to other listeners since I believe mine is not a strong transmitter after all. But it was only used a couple times since I don't want to be bothered by the FCC for any reason :)
However, SFB Morse did have a quite amazing idea that was quite useful in the 20th Century. I wonder if it can be kept useful during this 21st Century with all these new gadgets based on powerful MCU.
Nevertheless, I also wish Mr SFB Morse a Happy Birthday.
Thanks for the titles Aubrey -- I've noted them in my diary for future reading. Right now (for reasons that are a little mystifying even to me) I've been really busy and have been investing my reading time in "Urban Planning" material: what makes a city "alive?" It seems there's something of a revolution going on in this field, with old models giving way to some new (and pretty radical) ideas. A question in the back of my mind is "what might our new technologies contribute to this New Wave?"
antedeluvian 4/14/2012 6:51:29 PM User Rank Blogger
Books
I have just read two books that dealt with Morse and telegraphs.
The first was "The Victorian Internet" by Tom Standage and covered the whole telegraph age. I found it good, if a little shallow.
The second was called "Degrees Kelvin" by David Linley which dealt with the life of Sir William Thomson, Lord Kelvin. In describing his extensive efforts in the telegraph field it also covered most of the ground in "the Victorian Internet". Kelvin was involved in far more than just the telegraph though and so this is a far more detailed book, one one that was more to my taste.
To save this item to your list of favorite Microcontroller Central content so you can find it later in your Profile page, click the "Save It" button next to the item.
If you found this interesting or useful, please use the links to the services below to share it with other readers. You will need a free account with each service to share an item via that service.
Tweet This
